NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Milk Dupe J.Cat The Big Eye Pencil in Marshmallow

Hi All,

Today I will be reviewing J.Cat The Big Eye Pencil in Marshmallow which is an AMAZING dupe for NYX Jumbo Pencil in Milk.

I know NYX Jumbo Pencil is one of the most affordable drugstore makeup. However, Girlie Stuff from Facebook (I have mentioned her before in my previous post) is selling these J.Cat product which is a more cheaper alternative than NYX. And if you are getting something cheaper with the same quality... welll!! Who would not go for that?! 

I always buy most of my makeup from Girlie Stuff, and this time; when I ordered NYX Jumbo Pencil in Milk; she gave me J.Cat The Big Eye Pencil in Marshmallow with my order to review it.

So after a week of using both these pencils, I have concluded that J.Cat The Big Eye Pencil in Marshmallow is EXACT copy of NYX Jumbo Pencil in Milk. The creamy pigmentation, the smooth texture, the staying power, even the color is as same as NYX. No one can tell the difference between the two. You can see in the swatch below.

Blended

Even though J.Cat Pencil is same as NYX, with the rounded pencil for application, it is still a good alternative. 

NYX in Milk and J.Cat in Marshmallow

I had applied NYX on my one eye and J.Cat on my other as an eyeshadow base for work. By the end of the day, both of my eye makeup was still fresh without any fading or creasing. 

NYC Jumbo Pencil in Milk 

J.Cat The Big Eye Pencil in Marshmallow

The price of  NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in the market is around AED 30; where as Girlie Stuff sells it for AED 25 and J.Cat for AED 19. I believe it is a good deal for those who want to buy more of the jumbo pencils.

All in all, I am totally happy with J.Cat product. Though it is a mirror copy of NYX Jumbo Pencil; I am totally satisfied with this product. 

Stay Blessed, Stay Beautiful

Note: This product was sent to me for reviewing purposes and my opinion is completely honest.